Paid Membership Vs Subscription Models

The Psychology of Commitment: Why Paid Memberships are Outperforming Subscription Models.

Key Takeaways from this Issue:

1. Building sticky retention: Understanding the Sunk Cost Fallacy 
2. Crafting a strong value stack outside of product offerings
3. Balance value add ratios through leveraging partnership offerings

Subscription models are more saturated than ever. From the media we consume, to gym and meal subscription models, this generation is undoubtedly heading towards subscription fatigue.

Forward thinking brands are turning to a powerful alternative: paid memberships.

But what makes memberships so compelling, and why are they outperforming traditional subscription models in terms of customer retention and revenue growth?

The answer lies in consumer psychology and the way these models tap into our deepest decision-making processes.

The Power of Sunk Cost in Customer Retention​

sep blog: visual 1 (differences between subscription and membership models)

At the heart of the membership model’s success is the psychological principle of sunk cost. And the sunk cost fallacy is essentially a phenomenon that as humans, we have a natural tendency to finish what we’ve started once there’s time, effort, or money involved.

When applied ethically in business strategies, the sunk cost fallacy could be a powerful tool for marketers or even business owners trying to grow revenue and engagement.

sep blog visual 2: sunk cost illustration

Jay Myers, co-founder of Bold Commerce, highlights how successful membership programs leverage this principle to enhance customer loyalty. By reminding users of what they’re getting—and potentially what they’d be missing if they went elsewhere—brands create a strong incentive for continued engagement and reduce churn rates [1].

sep blog visual 2b: sunk cost flow chart

Spotify exemplifies this customer retention strategy: the more time subscribers spend building playlists and allowing the algorithm to learn their preferences, the harder it becomes to leave the platform, thus increasing customer lifetime value.

The Value Stack: What Paid Memberships Offer Beyond Subscriptions

While traditional subscription models often focus on a single aspect—be it replenishment, curation, or access—successful memberships offer a comprehensive “value stack.”

This approach addresses one of the key vulnerabilities of subscription models: the inevitability of subscriber fatigue, which can lead to, you guessed it – high churn rates.

Grab has been one of the pioneers in establishing a growing paid membership program. Its GrabUnlimited membership program serves as a prime case study in membership monetisation within the APAC region.

By offering a suite of benefits across its various services—ride-hailing, food delivery, and digital payments—Grab has created a value proposition that goes far beyond any single service.

Information about Grab’s services and membership program is publicly available through their official website and press releases.

What about businesses with a more focused product range?

The Perception of Increasing Value through Monthly Payments

Creating engaging membership programs requires a touch of creativity and to deliver value directly to your customers’ needs, here are some strategies to consider:

sep blog visual 3: value propositions in a loyalty program

Increasing Perceived Value through Partnerships in APAC

A key strategy in successful membership programs, particularly evident in the APAC/SEA region, is continuously increasing the perceived value without significantly impacting the company’s bottom line. This is often achieved through strategic partnerships and negotiated benefits.

For example:

  1. Singapore Airlines KrisFlyer (Southeast Asia): Singapore Airlines’ KrisFlyer program partners with a wide range of businesses, from hotels and car rental companies to retail outlets. These partnerships allow KrisFlyer to offer members a broad spectrum of benefits beyond just air travel, significantly increasing the perceived value of membership without directly impacting Singapore Airlines’ costs.
  2. GrabRewards (Southeast Asia): Grab’s rewards program partners with numerous merchants across different Southeast Asian countries. Members can use their points for discounts or freebies from these partners, enhancing the value proposition of the membership without Grab bearing the full cost of these rewards.
sep blog visual 4cross offering values in membership programs

So, are Paid Memberships the Future of Customer Engagement?

As we’ve explored throughout this article, paid memberships are outperforming traditional subscription models for several key reasons:

Psychological Buy-In

Getting your customers emotionally invested works in favour for your membership programs. Unlike subscriptions, which can feel like recurring bills, memberships build a sense of belonging and investment.

Building True Value Stacks

True value stacks go beyond monetary value, enabling a holistic perspective when curating your program experience will relief your program of subscription fatigue. 

Increasing the Value to Cost Ratio

Adding on to point 2, programs that seek out partnerships and external value adds are able to create the perception of continuously increasing value, often without significantly impacting the company’s bottom line. Creating a sustainable, win-win situation. 

The shift from subscriptions to memberships represents a fundamental change in how businesses are approaching customer relationships, and the ones who are locking in a single value subscription program is at risk of losing that emotional connection with their consumers. 

 

As we move forward the coming year, businesses are leveraging memberships and experience driven campaigns to drive long term brand recognition, engagement, and loyalty.

 

 

Related Posts

零售與餐飲生意點解要搞會員制?5大理由話你知! 會員積分系統在現代商業環境中扮演著至關重要的策略性角色,不僅是企業與顧客之間建立長期關係的重要橋樑,更是提升品牌競爭力的關鍵工具。這些系統經過精心設計,不僅能有效獎勵顧客的持續支持和忠誠度,還能透過多樣化的積分機制和獎勵方案,激勵顧客增加消費頻率和購買量,從而建立起穩固的品牌黏著度。通過這種互惠互利的機制,企業可以培養更多忠實顧客,同時顧客也能從中獲得更多實質的購物優惠和專屬權益。

屈臣氏會員計劃點解咁成功?零售商必學嘅吸客鎖客秘訣! 喺香港,講起會員積分計劃,屈臣氏(Watsons)絕對係其中一個最成功嘅例子!無論你係平時買日用品,定係專攻護膚保健品,屈臣氏會員計劃都總有啲優惠等緊你。 作為亞洲最大嘅保健及美容零售商,屈臣氏點解可以靠會員制度鎖住咁多熟客?如果你都係零售商,想知點樣打造一個勁吸客嘅會員計劃,千祈唔好錯過以下重點!

會員系統APP:香港零售業翻單神器,提升銷售與顧客忠誠度的必勝攻略! 在香港這個競爭激烈的零售市場,如何提升顧客「翻單力」並強化品牌忠誠度,成為許多零售商的核心課題。而會員系統APP 已成為解決這一挑戰的關鍵策略!它不只是管理會員的工具,更是數據驅動的營銷利器,幫助零售商精準行銷、提升顧客體驗,最終帶動業績增長。